November 26, 2025: LEGAL CHALLENGE UPDATE

On November 18, 2025, the Court of Appeal for Ontario ruled Niagara Neighbours for Community Safety’s (NNCS) leave to appeal was dismissed with costs. NNCS has been directed to pay all of the outstanding cost awards owing to St. Felix Centre of $27,348.82 plus interest (interest has not been included). Contributions can made through this GoFundMe site by December 21, 2025. Thank you.

Background

NNCS filed a (final) leave to appeal the 50-bed shelter at 629 Adelaide St W. Key issues: zoning compliance, courts did not rule while construction proceeded calling it “premature", and limits on expert evidence. The judges ruled against NNCS. 100% of our fundraising efforts have gone towards the legal challenge and our funds are exhausted (our full accounting has been made public to those who contributed over $50). This has been a two year effort including going to court three times—this was our final appeal. The outstanding amount represents St. Felix Centre’s legal costs, any money raised will go towards that amount.

629 Adelaide Street West remains zoned Employment Industrial I1 D3 under the City of Toronto's former By-law 438-86. However, Section 6 of the Municipal Shelter By-law clearly prohibits shelters in I1 D3 buildings under bylaw 438-86 and because shelters are residential this building, the way it is currently zoned, is not permitted use. NNCS has never received an clear explanation from the City of Toronto.

Patio Fence

The new patio fence, constructed on the north side of the building, was illegal due to the height, being a privacy fence, and it's proximity to Tecumseth and Adelaide - under City's own bylaw: Chapter 743 STREETS AND SIDEWALKS, USE OF. It was neighbourhood residents who brought the matter to the attention of City of Toronto staff—not St. Felix Centre. It then required additional approvals from the City of Toronto's Community Council even though the fence had been (illegally) in place for months.

October/November 2025 UPDATE: Six Months Without Action from St. Felix Centre or TSSS

It has now been nearly six months (June 2025) since neighbours first filed complaints with St. Felix Centre and Toronto Shelter & Support Services (TSSS) regarding the severe lighting issues coming from the shelter. Exterior lights were sited too high and blaze high lumen lighting into homes and onto private properties and backyards making them essentially unusable. Despite repeated follow-ups, the problem remains completely unresolved.

Toronto Shelter Standards

Page 3: All emergency and transitional shelters funded or operated by the City of Toronto must adhere to the TSS.


Page 21: Shelter providers are required to collaborate with neighbours and maintain a respectful, responsive relationship with the surrounding community.

Toronto Shelter Standards: https://www.toronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/9828-Toronto-Shelter-Standards230328AODA.pdf

Shelter Design & Technical Guidelines

Page 29: Shelters should be integrated into their communities — not at odds with them.


Page 147: Artificial lighting must allow safe access while not negatively impacting neighbours.


Page 246: Lights must be shielded to prevent glare or light trespass.
Page 246: Exterior lighting design must follow the City’s Best Practices for Effective Lighting, Bird-Friendly Development Guidelines, and Green Development Standard.

Shelter Design & Technical Guidelines: https://www.toronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/8e2c-SDTG-2023-Release-FinalJuly-11AODA.pdf

Current Reality

The large window facing many of our properties to the south of the building is now covered in brown paper — a temporary measure that has already been removed multiple times. The extremely bright exterior high lumen floodlights remain turned off, yet there has been no outreach, collaboration, or discussion of a long-term solution with the neighbourhood.

The interior lighting, combined with bright white window coverings, turns the building into a glowing beacon at dusk and throughout the evening — in the middle of a quiet residential area. This level of light trespass into our homes and yards is completely unacceptable, especially during spring, summer, and fall when we use our outdoor spaces.

HVAC Noise

The new hospital-grade HVAC system and other mechanical equipment on the rooftop of the building continues to drone for over 14 hours a day. Today marks more than 60 days since our neighbourhood reported this issue to St. Felix Centre.

Despite clear obligations laid out in the Toronto Shelter Standards and the Shelter Technical & Design Guidelines, we have received no response at all. On October 30, 2025, the City of Toronto issued St. Felix Centre and the building owner with an an Order to Comply with the noise bylaw, however, the loud droning noise continues as we await mitigation measures.

We should never have been forced to escalate concerns to 311 and the City’s noise bylaw process given the City’s own statements about being responsible neighbours.

Good Neighbour Policy

TSSS Director Loretta Ramadhin stated to CTV on March 4, 2025: “The city is committed to being good neighbours. We have a good neighbour policy because we want the shelter to be successful in the community.” https://www.ctvnews.ca/toronto/article/this-parking-lot-is-not-the-solution-etobicoke-residents-push-back-against-shelter-plan/

One Community Solutions - Community Safety Teams

The ongoing daily surveillance of our neighbourhood by the One Community Solutions Community Safety Teams is deeply intrusive and inhumane. Neighbours have filed multiple complaints regarding the invasion of privacy caused by individuals watching our homes, photographing private property, monitoring our movements, and now knowing where many residents live. They have no identification and we are unaware why they are here in the very heart of our neighbourhood.

These individuals are stationed around the building—watching homes and the comings and goings of our neighbours. They are also stationed at the laneways and are very aware when people leave their homes. People feel very intimidated by the constant observation particularly women and seniors.

These individuals do not have identification, and we have no clear understanding of why they are in our neighbourhood or under what authority they operate.

Would it be considered acceptable for residents to stand outside the shelter at 629 Adelaide Street West and observe the comings and goings of staff and shelter residents in the same manner?

This situation is deeply concerning and unacceptable. We continue to be concerned about the siting of a 24-hour emergency shelter in the heart of our residential neighbourhood.

February 2, 2025: UPDATE

THANK YOU FOR HELPING US SAVE OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD

Thank you to everyone who contributed to our neighbourhood legal appeal. We are awaiting updates from our lawyer on the next steps. Through various fundraising efforts, we have reached our goal. Sincere appreciation to those who have supported this fight since October 2023.

This past week, we learned that the facility—originally set to open in November 2023—has been delayed yet again to Q2 2025. Meanwhile, over $600,000 is being spent annually on its lease, while the building remains completely unused. You can still read about the details of our neighbourhood fight below.

January 15, 2025: UPDATE

HELP US SAVE OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD

Thank you to everyone who continues to donate to our neighbourhood legal appeal. We await news from our lawyer regarding the City of Toronto and St. Felix's response to the appeal. Please read the story in today's National Post by Derek Finkle about the City of Toronto's shelter siting process: https://nationalpost.com/feature/secret-homeless-shelter-next-door

December 2, 2024: UPDATE

HELP US SAVE OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD!

On Friday, November 29, 2024, Niagara Neighbours for Community Safety lawyer, Eric Gillespie, submitted our Legal Appeal to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Divisional Court). We will keep you informed of the next steps. We are very grateful to those who have contributed. We do urgently require donations to help fund the Legal Appeal. If you haven't yet donated all contributions are helpful. If you have donated, please consider topping up your donation! Thank you.

October 28, 2024

HELP US SAVE OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD!

The City of Toronto, Mayor Chow, and Deputy Mayor/Councillor Malik are planning to open a 50-bed, 24-hour emergency shelter—with the distribution of needles, pipes, and other drug paraphernalia—directly in the heart of historic Portugal Square a residential family-oriented Toronto neighbourhood surrounded by homes and close to two elementary schools. 629 Adelaide Street West is the wrong place for this shelter. We are asking you, please, to donate to our legal appeal (please read more details about the legal challenge below).

The planned shelter is just 54 metres from St. Mary Catholic Elementary School and 235 metres from Niagara Street Public School—in the heart of a residential family-oriented neighbourhood where children walk, bike, play, and go to school.

With the 10-year lease signed in late 2023, the operating and leasing costs for 50 beds will reach $45 million—fully funded by the City of Toronto. The shelter, originally scheduled to open in November 2023, remains closed due to multiple inexplicable delays, now pushed to the first quarter of 2025. With planned renovations of more than $4 million, if completed, the facility will feature cramped dormitory-style accommodations with up to 50% of its residents facing serious mental health and addiction issues.

WHO WE ARE

Niagara Neighbours for Community Safety (NNCS) is a Toronto community group, located in the Queen and Bathurst Streets area, dedicated to ensuring public safety in our neighbourhood. We strongly oppose the City’s plan to lease and convert 629 Adelaide Street West into a 50-bed, 24-hour emergency shelter.

OUR FUNDRAISING GOAL

NNCS aims to raise $25,000 to cover the costs of the next phase of our legal challenge a legal appeal. All donations will go directly toward this effort. Our neighbourhood has been fighting this legal battle against the City of Toronto and St. Felix Centre for nearly a year, with generous supporters contributing amounts ranging from $35 to $5,000. We are deeply grateful for every contribution.

CALL TO ACTION

Your donation to the NNCS legal appeal will help prevent potential tragedies in our neighbourhood, and send a strong message to City of Toronto staff, Mayor Chow, and Deputy Mayor/Councillor Malik. Neighbourhoods are fed up with the complete lack of concern for public safety. Our fight is for all Toronto neighbourhoods, especially as the City plans to site 20 additional shelters across Toronto. Please read about our year-long fight below.

NO ACCOUNTABILITY

For over one year our neighbourhood has tried to have our voices heard. The City has ignored our letters, petitions, rallies, and requests to meet—failing to engage with us in any meaningful way. Freedom of Information findings are disturbing as they reveal confusion, mismanagement, and deliberate attempts to circumvent democratic processes by elected officials, City of Toronto staff, and other key decision makers. Now, we are launching a legal appeal to stop the reckless and dangerous siting of this shelter. The shelter site has no outdoor space and with the distribution of needles, pipes, and other drug paraphernalia to shelter residents, it will effectively turn our residential neighbourhood into an outdoor area for illegal drug dealing and drug use.

WHY THIS LEGAL APPEAL IS SO IMPORTANT

We acknowledge the serious public health crisis of homelessness, addiction, and mental health facing Toronto and Canada. However, the ongoing disregard for neighbourhood public safety is unacceptable. Experts on homelessness, mental health, and addictions in Toronto have foreseen this crisis. It is unjust and unfair for Toronto neighbourhoods to not only be silenced by politicians and City of Toronto staff, but as well to bear the consequences for decades of systemic failures by all levels of government. We have heard Toronto local politicians blame mistakes made decades ago, despite having held their positions for just as long.

OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD LEGAL CHALLENGE AND APPEAL

In December 2023, due to a lack of transparency and genuine community engagement from the City of Toronto, NNCS submitted a $200 zoning-use review application to clarify the zoning by-laws for 629 Adelaide Street West. The City’s Building Division responded that a municipal shelter was “not a permitted use,” but provided no explanation. Following this our lawyer, Eric Gillespie, filed a notice of application with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice on February 6, 2024. After multiple legal submissions a final hearing was held on March 28, 2024 resulting in Justice Brownstone ruling against us. NNCS is now filing a critical legal appeal to address errors related to prematurity and expert evidence, among other issues. We have faced significant challenges, but backing down was never an option for our close-knit neighbourhood.

THE FACTS: BUILDING LEASED—YET THE SHELTER REMAINS CLOSED

10-year lease signed: October/November 2023

Annual Lease: $640K

10-year operating and leasing costs: $50 million for 50 beds

10-year cost per bed: $1,000,000

Year 629 Adelaide Street West was built: 1947

Renovation costs: Nearly $4.0 million, please find below a selection of renovations costs from a recent Freedom of Information request (updated costs are also included):

Approvals: Fully approved by the City of Toronto & City Council

Funding: Fully funded by the City of Toronto

Original planned opening date: November 2023 (then, multiple inexplicable delays)

Official Opening: July 21, 2025

Concerns: This project is reckless and a misuse of taxpayer funds—it must be stopped immediately.

WHY OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD IS FIGHTING THIS SHELTER

URGENT PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERNS

The 24-hour emergency shelter, to be operated by St. Felix Centre, will distribute needles, pipes, and other drug paraphernalia to shelter residents, effectively turning our residential neighbourhood into an outdoor area for illegal drug dealing and drug use. The building site is essentially land-locked, surrounded by roads, laneways, and homes—with no outdoor space—in complete contravention of the City’s own 300-page Shelter Design & Technical Guidelines.

ARE 24-HOUR EMERGENCY SHELTERS SAFE?

Recent research has shown that shelters are not safe spaces. A study released in April 2024 by the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) revealed a shocking 283% increase in violence in Toronto shelters over the past decade—violence that spills into our surrounding neighbourhoods. Meanwhile, the City of Toronto is apparently developing a “Shelter Safety Action Plan” without any input from our neighbourhood. We fully expect there will be no comprehensive "Plan" in place, nor adequately trained staff, if this shelter opens in quarter one 2025.

Homeless advocates have also voiced their serious concerns about City of Toronto shelter operations. In a recent CBC report, an exasperated Toronto homeless advocate expressed her worries: “Shelters are not objectively safer, and people avoid them for legitimate reasons: to preserve their autonomy, and because of oppressive rules, violence, theft, death, and diseases.”

ST. FELIX CENTRE

St. Felix Centre currently manages a 24-hour respite site at 69 Fraser Avenue in Liberty Village and previously managed a similar service at 25 Augusta Avenue. Residents and businesses around both of these sites have reported significant issues with violence, intimidation, crime, and open drug dealing and drug use. St. Felix Centre appears to be unable to safely manage respite sites and, disturbingly, has no prior experience managing a 24-hour (critical care) emergency shelter. We have no trust nor confidence that this City of Toronto funded service operator will be able to safely manage this facility in the heart of our family-oriented residential neighbourhood.

Additionally concerning are recent jobs posted online by St. Felix Centre undoubtedly related to 629 Adelaide Street West. The workplace description completely validates our repeated public safety concerns: “Interaction with guests, residents, and other community members with complex needs related to poverty, trauma, health issues, substance use, and food and housing insecurity; high levels of trauma content and pressure; and, safety precautions due to exposure to pets, pests, hazardous waste, and contagious illnesses”—located in the heart of a residential neighbourhood.

NO OUTDOOR SPACE & THE PLANNED PATIO

The City of Toronto and St. Felix Centre leased a land-locked building which has no outdoor space—in complete contravention of the City of Toronto's own 300-page Shelter Design and Technical Guidelines.

Recent investigations, uncovered through Freedom of Information requests, have revealed a troubling collaboration between the City of Toronto’s Transportation Services, St. Felix Centre, and their contractor. Together, it appears they planned the installation of a narrow, poorly situated patio on City property on the north side of the building, altering a previous design. From recent photographs it looks like costly excavation work within the building was undertaken to establish the existing footing depths. Emails show this work was part of a deliberate attempt to bypass the Committee of Adjustment, silencing our neighbourhood’s concerns yet again. This disregard for our voices is frustrating and disheartening.

The lack of outdoor space means that this narrow and poorly situated patio—intended for a 50-bed, 24-hour emergency shelter—will inevitably turn into an outdoor smoking and congregating area for shelter residents facing directly onto multiple homes, just metres from residential living rooms and bedroom windows. This decision is not just thoughtless; it’s reckless and demonstrates the complete disregard for our neighbourhood.

Most alarming is that without any outdoor space, drug use and related activities will inevitably spill into our laneways, schoolyards, sidewalks, church grounds, and private properties. This raises serious concerns about Mayor Olivia Chow, Deputy Mayor/Councillor Ausma Malik, and the City of Toronto's commitment to protecting our neighbourhood’s interests—and even more importantly, our local democracy. It’s infuriating—clearly, residents who are voters and taxpayers—do not matter.

WEAPONS AND PROHIBITED ITEMS AT SHELTERS

The City of Toronto’s own ‘Shelter Standards’ state that service operators must seek police guidance when managing weapons or prohibited items. Yet, here we are, facing the reckless decision to locate a shelter in the heart of a family-oriented neighbourhood with the very real possibility of weapons on our local streets. This isn’t just irresponsible; it’s unacceptable. How can the City of Toronto justify putting Toronto neighbourhoods at risk like this?

In fact, just this past summer, the Toronto Catholic District School Board surrounded St. Mary Catholic Elementary School—54 meters from the planned shelter and mere metres from the supervised consumption site at 168 Bathurst Street—with ten-foot metal fences to lock children in. This fence symbolizes our public safety concerns and the issues that will arise in our neighbourhood if this shelter opens.

SHELTER LAYOUT

The shelter layout will feature cramped dormitory-style accommodations, with at least 50% of its residents facing serious mental health and addiction issues. Dormitory-style shelters are a dangerous and outdated solution to the homelessness and housing crisis. Recent research and multiple reputable media outlets have repeatedly reported that shelters compromise not only public safety for surrounding neighbourhoods, but also for shelter staff and residents.

SHELTER COMMUNITY LIASON COMMITTEE (CLC)

The City of Toronto website claims that the City, Deputy Mayor/Councillor Malik, and St. Felix Centre will determine the membership of the CLC. Yet those of us who have voiced concerns about the siting of this shelter will be undemocratically excluded from participating in the CLC—as we were excluded from the Community (Safety) Walk held on May 6, 2024.

The “catchment area” for the CLC, referenced on the City of Toronto’s website, has never been disclosed to our neighbourhood, with vague references to established condominium boards, resident associations, business groups, and local community organizations. This facility is surrounded by residential homes—not businesses or condominiums. Residents who live closest to the facility are not represented by any of these organizations and have expressed a strong desire to participate in the CLC, yet there has been no response from the City of Toronto.

DANGEROUS PEDESTRIAN, BICYCLE, AND TRAFFIC SAFETY ISSUES

629 Adelaide Street West is completely surrounded by public right-of-ways. On the north and east side are public sidewalks with a boulevard easement. Running along this public sidewalk is a marked and heavily used bike lane that feeds into the city core. On the south and west side are laneways which must remain open and accessible at all times. In the south-west corner hidden away from the street, directly behind 629 Adelaide Street West, is a large hydro vault.

Without outdoor space, and the site's perilous location on busy one-way streets (Adelaide Street West and Portugal Square), serious safety concerns arise. The heavily used bike lane, surrounded by laneways, St. Mary's Parish busy church parking lot, and multiple blind spots exacerbate these risks. Notably, the facility's front door is situated in a dangerous traffic blind spot at the exact location where Adelaide Street West takes a dangerous 90-degree angle. We expect multiple unfortunate accidents if the shelter opens.

NO PUBLIC PARKING & NO SAFE DELIVERY AREA

There is very limited public parking in our residential neighbourhood and the land-locked building site lacks a safe and spacious designated service delivery area. The presence of multiple delivery trucks—needed for food, linens, and garbage collection, etc.—will create dangerous and disruptive situations as they back in and out of the narrow laneways onto the busy street and bike lane of Adelaide Street West. This issue will be further aggravated by the loud truck back-up alarms and the facility's close proximity to numerous homes, intensifying our neighbourhood's serious concerns about the reckless siting of this facility.

EMERGENCY VEHICLES IN THE HEART OF OUR NEIGHBOURHOOD

We are very concerned with the impact to our neighbourhood by emergency service vehicles—police, ambulance, fire—that will need to attend to the 24-hour (critical care) emergency shelter. We have witnessed the social chaos unfold at other shelters, respite sites, and supervised consumption sites, where violence, deaths, and drug overdoses occur.

INDUSTRIAL KITCHEN, GARBAGE ISSUES, RODENTS, ODOURS

629 Adelaide Street West is an outdated industrial building that was only ever meant for manufacturing and storage. Now, the City of Toronto plans to spend over $2.8 million to convert it into a residential space, complete with a full industrial kitchen to prepare three meals and two snacks daily for over 50 shelter residents. This is essentially turning the building into a full-scale restaurant in the heart of residential neighbourhood.

The kitchen, to be located in the southwest corner, will generate garbage, odours, cooking grease, attracting rodents, and other pests. Because the laneways can't be blocked due to the Hydro Vault agreement, garbage bins and recycling containers must be squeezed either inside the building (there is no basement) or onto the public sidewalk on the north and east sides—where there’s simply not enough space. This poses a very serious and dangerous health hazard.

The sheer volume of waste generated daily will be overwhelming. This building was never intended to function as a 24-hour emergency shelter and dining hall for 50 people. It's reckless and unacceptable.

TORONTO POLICE SERVICES

Finally, and most alarming, is that Toronto Police Services has advised residents to increase home security due to the expected rise in criminal activity linked to this shelter.

WHAT IS THE SOLUTION?

If opened, this planned 24-hour emergency shelter will serve individuals who are not only homeless, but many who struggle with serious mental health and addiction issues. For these facilities to be successful, they must be well-designed, provide the right services, delivered in the right way, by the right people, and in the right location. Unfortunately, 629 Adelaide Street West does not meet any of these requirements.

Instead, it reflects a rushed decision following unsuccessful lease negotiations at another site, where the landlord changed their mind due to significant public safety concerns for their neighbourhood. Poor planning, poor project management, and poor design leads to detrimental outcomes for neighbourhoods. 

WE ARE ON PUBLIC RECORD

Our neighbourhood is on public record for one year now advising the City of Toronto, Mayor Chow, and Deputy Mayor/Councillor Malik of all our concerns. Stop the dangerous siting of this shelter in our neighbourhood.

We are deeply grateful for every contribution to our legal appeal. Thank you for reading about year-long fight and for your support!