
Help me sue my former uni for whistleblower retaliation
0% complete
$134 raised of $600
2 donations
Update 1: Thank you to everyone who has privately contacted me with messages of support. As I indicated in my first draft of this post, I have been very scared and hesitant to discuss what happened to me at my previous institution publicly. Your kind words have meant a lot to me.
---
My name is Emily Heydon. I am a current PhD student and Schomburg Fellow in the Philosophy, Politics, and Economics program at the University at Buffalo, where I am writing a dissertation in game theory. However, three years ago, the University of California almost succeeded in ending my career.
Before I transferred to my current PhD program in Buffalo in August 2024, I was a PhD student in the Department of Logic and Philosophy of Science (LPS) at UC Irvine. At one point in time, LPS was my dream PhD program — the LPS department is highly ranked and generally well-regarded, and some of my undergraduate mentors had attended the same program. I tried to do my due diligence before definitively accepting my offer from the LPS program; I visited the program in person in early 2020, consulted with my mentors, and spoke with many current and former program attendees. In the end, I turned down many prestigious competing PhD offers — including an offer from Carnegie Mellon and two selective fellowships at Duke — in order to attend LPS. Because the program at LPS was supposedly one of the best in my broader field (philosophy of science), I was led to believe that attending that program would put me in a good position on the job market.
Unfortunately, the vision that I was sold through the application and interview process was completely at odds with my actual experience in the LPS program. I discovered a toxic “bro culture” in which the research and opinions of the women in the program were often minimized or dismissed. Women and minority students were frequently handed failing grades on the department’s written qualifying exam with little to no justification or explanation. Many of these failing grades led to women and minority students being expelled from the program for no obvious reason. (In the words of a wise senior PhD student from our sister department, “They fail brilliant people!”) Student-led DEI efforts and calls for transparency around the grading of qualifying exams were consistently met with obstinance from certain faculty and administrators. While some faculty were consistently kind, others were excessively argumentative and mercurial, lashing out at their own advisees both in private and in class. I became anxious and struggled to speak in classes. In retrospect, I probably should have begun making plans to transfer out of the program after the first term. Still, due to the high rankings of the program and its faculty, I was convinced to stay and try to stick things out.
Things took a turn for the worse in late 2021, when I stumbled across evidence that appeared to indicate that certain researchers affiliated with the department were linked to the fossil-fuel industry in ways that could violate university conflict-of-interest policies, state law, government funding regulations, and the integrity of particular research projects. I grew increasingly distressed about what I had found. Over the course of the next three months, I struggled to sleep and eat. My pre-existing immune disease worsened, and I had migraines almost every day. My weight plummeted to the point that bones stuck out of my chest. I clenched my jaw at night, and large holes and chips began appearing in my teeth. Finally, at the end of that fall term, I decided to try reaching out to UCI’s Office of the Whistleblower, hoping that they could provide some resolution to the unusual circumstances in which I found myself. Unfortunately, that office declined to investigate my concerns. Moreover, they openly confessed to violating my confidentiality by passing along my concerns to an associate dean. The result was that the dean in question informed the LPS department that I had gone to the Whistleblower for help. Rather than helping me, the office had effectively outed me as a whistleblower to my home department.
What followed was a series of collaborative efforts between several members of the department faculty and the university administration to malign the quality of my work, surveil me excessively, terminate my teaching assistant contract, and expel me from the program. Certain faculty took it upon themselves to obtain and monitor emails I sent from my private (non-university) Gmail account, lurk outside my apartment building, and instruct other faculty not to speak to me. Internal emails I obtained through a California Public Records Act request showed these same faculty repeatedly discussing matters pertaining to me in a derogatory manner. Then, in mid-2023, the department awarded me two consecutive failing grades on my written qualifying exam — a result that seems odd, given that the work I submitted for the exam included two evolutionary game theory projects that are now both published in the well-regarded journal Philosophy of Science, as well as a third, computation-heavy paper in formal epistemology that has received a couple of conference acceptances. I was previously a 4.0 student, and I never received a satisfactory explanation for why these failing grades were awarded to me. I hired an education attorney to help me appeal these grades — twice. The university administration consistently refused to provide any outside review of my grades. I also - twice - asked the university to begin an investigation into the ongoing pattern of retaliation against me. They refused. The result was that I was terminated from my teaching assistant position, lost my tuition waiver, and (finally) was dismissed from the program in January 2024.
While I had already received an offer to transfer to my current department in Buffalo, the months between January 2024 (when I was definitively terminated) and August 2024 (when U at Buffalo could begin paying me my regular salary) were exceedingly difficult. I applied for part-time teaching and tutoring work, but I could not secure enough hours, even while working simultaneously for multiple companies. I applied for unemployment and was informed that lost teaching assistant wages did not qualify me for unemployment in the state of California. The university informed my off-campus student landlord that I was no longer enrolled as a student, with the result that the landlord forced me to abruptly move out under threat of eviction. I could not afford another apartment in Irvine, but I managed to find a cheap under-the-table rental in Buffalo. The result was that I was forced to drive through late-March snowstorms and other hazardous conditions in order to move myself across the country. Gas money for the trip came mainly from friends, both online and in-person. I could not consistently afford hotels along the way, and parking in the mountains was so cold that I could often only manage an hour of sleep at a time. I miraculously managed not to crash my car during this particular six-day misadventure. Still, surviving the summer was difficult, and I took on a range of odd, low-paid, and dangerous work just to afford rent and discounted McDonald’s meals.
While I have repeatedly tried to negotiate matters with the University of California and its legal team, they have made it clear that they have no intention of investigating the retaliation against me, apologizing for the callous behavior I experienced at the hands of many of their employees, instituting stronger anti-bias policies to protect women and minority students during the qualifying process, or investigating the conflicts of interest that led to my initial complaints. With all of this in mind, I believe that the only way to hold UC accountable and force needed changes in my former department is through legal action. In the next week, I plan to begin the process of filing a civil suit against the university in Orange County Superior Court, alleging violations of both state whistleblower statutes and the Fair Employment and Housing Act. The initial fundraiser goal represents the cost of filing the court complaint and hiring a process server. Any additional contributions will go towards helping me secure limited or full legal representation. While many employment attorneys work on commission, those who specialize in academic employment issues generally do not - which makes justice more difficult to obtain for those of us who work in academia. As I am still actively searching for an attorney, I would be grateful for any specific advice or leads that people can provide in that direction.
While I am currently limited in what information about my case I can provide publicly, I will try my best to answer private questions about any of the above. Please feel free to contact me with any specific questions.
