
Backing Paul Pickett's Legal Challenge for Democracy
0% complete
$800 raised of $7K
5 donations
Do you love Democracy? Are you one who loves to point out that we actually live in a Constitutional Republic? Do you like funding political causes to support your values and having the back of people fighting to defend the fabric of our society?
If you said "Yes" to one or more of the above: Well, have I got a cause for you!
My name is Paul Pickett and a month ago I would have said:
"I am fighting for the rights of Republican committee members in the Oneida County Republican Committee (OCRC)."
But with the case going to the Appellate Court, I can now say,
"I am fighting for the rights of my Committee and to clarify the rules governing all Political Committees in the State of New York!"
The Story:
For a year our Chairman has not been allowing members to access our rights and at the September 25, 2025 meeting the body was pushed to pass a sweeping revision of our committee's Bylaws which included removing those rights entirely.
Want to point out that a rule has been broken? Nope. Want the body to vote one a decision, rather than just have the Chair make the decision for you? Nope. And a Bonus: Sit down or be removed from the meeting! (Spoiler: I was removed from a meeting for insisting on the rules being followed - and not by a vote of the body, but an illegal removal via the building owner, encouraged by the chair.)
The Case:
I filed a legal challenge, to reverse the removal of our rights, called an Article 78 Petition - titled Pickett v Roser against the Chairman of the Oneida County Republican Committee and the Committee, itself - and I lost at the first judicial court level, which is called the Supreme Court. (Yes, the first of three levels is called the "Supreme Court". Next is Appellate, and then Court of Appeals).
I am planning an Appeal of my case. I lost due to what I believe to be an incorrect interpretation of the Election Law and a former ruling by a higher court that applied a 10-day time limit to file my case, rather than a 4-month time limit.
Regarding my challenge to the time limit, the presiding judge said "I think you are making these great arguments, but. I still think my hands are tied." The judge encouraged me to appeal. This case would come to the 4nd District Appellate Court and they would have the authority to override previous president, if they see fit, which the lower court did believe they had the freedom to do, in this case.
After some follow-up research, I have decided to go forward with an Appeal, and I am asking for your financial support.
The Funding:
Thus far, I have received $1,000 from individuals, and that has been a massive help in countering the costs of the first case (totaling around $2,000). I have been asked to make a convenient method for individuals to donate, as they wish, hence this GoFundMe Campaign.
I have represented myself, thus far. If the court grants my request to proceed "as a poor person" the court fees will be waived (a total of around $500) and I could be assigned an attorney at no cost to myself. That would leave just hundreds of dollars of printing costs and any time off of work that I need to sacrifice in order to do this.
If the public funds me beyond $5,000, I can shop for my own attorney - one with unique experiences or a passion for this subject.
If I need to represent myself again, I will do so. However, I would appreciate the benefit of experience in navigating the process, researching, crafting arguments, and providing a full, professional representation of the case in court.
The Official Documents:
The official title of this case is Pickett v. Roser, the case ID# is EFCA2025-004198 and you are free to browse all of the files and exhibits from the concluded lower court case here:
For reviewing the video and audio recordings, you can find them at:
You can see the full filing details and documents on New York's Court System website:
How Funding will be Used:
If funding stays well below $5,000 it will go to printing and mailing costs. transportation, and personal compensation for my time off of work. (fyi, I spent over 100 hours on the first level of this case and missed over 40 hours of work).
Learning Fast:
This is my first court case ever, and I have been learning fast for these past months. I have five years of experience in student government in college, which is why the rule violations were so clear to me. I have seen these rules run correctly in an organization before.
There is no reason that a full, Republican Committee cannot rise up and do this - to set a good example for how Democratic and Constitutional Republican principals can operate - not only in our government but in all organizations with a voting body - where the members are intended to be the highest authority.
Final Call:
Any amount that you would like to give would join in a generous pile by people who want to see problems like this challenged. Whether you're thinking in terms of five dollars or tens, or hundreds of dollars, it would be most welcome, and you can keep updated on how this case goes in the following places:
Facebook:
Paul Pickett, Mike Fellows, and Jacob Morgan
Radio:
Keeler in the Morning

