Save the View Now: Brooklyn Bridge
Pierhouse, a hotel and residential complex on the south side of Brooklyn Bridge , is obstructing the world-famous views of the historic bridge and Manhattan Skyline. The plans are inconsistent with what was presented to the comunity in 2006. Working together is the only way to stop the Pierhouse from completely obstructing these scenic vistas.
The northern hotel complex of the Pierhouse is now well above the 100 foot limit clearly stated in the 2005 Modified General Project Plan. It is also apparent that Toll Brothers, the developer, plans to exceed the 55 foot building height limit set for the southern condo building.
We now believe litigation is a necessary step to achieve our goals. To this end, we formed a legal entity known as People for Preserving the View Foundation (“PFPVF”). We are seeking donation to help with legal costs associated with pursuing this litigation. PFPVF staff is strictly volunteer and receives no compensation. PFPVF has filed an application with the Internal Revenue Service for non-profit/501(c)(3). For further details on tax deductions, please see the IRS document here for more information.
Please join our Facebook page here: https://www.facebook.com/savetheviewnow?fref=ts
I hope you will read the following about saving the view of the iconic Brooklyn Bridge and the Manhattan skyline for our generation and all future generations:
With regards to the Pierhouse lawsuit #2 about the breach of the only legal Scenic View Plan in the City (the Manhattan Skyline), we have spoken to a well-known attorney who has been successful in lawsuits against the City with regard to preservation issues. He requires a $7,000 retainer to review our lawsuit documentation to see if we have an opportunity to appeal Judge Knipel's decision. (The Judge did NOT decide on the merits. He said that because The Pierhouse lawsuit #1 - against the first building shown in the photo on our gofundme page - was barred by the Statute of Limitations, that this lawsuit was also barred. We disagree with his finding and want to appeal. The attorney we are speaking to thinks he can help but needs to review the lawsuit documents.)
People on this end are losing hope because we have no money left. (100% of donations were spent on legal fees. We, the board members paid for miscellaneous expenses out-of-pocket.) I know that WE - everyone here together - can DO this
Please donate any amount, if you can for Giving Tuesday. We are all UNPAID volunteers (with day jobs) and ALL DONATIONS will go towards this attorney's retainer. We have poured our own money, sweat (and lots of tears) into saving the view of the Brooklyn Bridge for us and all future generations. Now we need your help.
Please find it in your hearts to help save the only protected Scenic View Plane in the city. Please also SHARE, SHARE, SHARE - our court deadline approaches: http://savetheviewnow.org/donate/
Even $5.00 will help. THANK YOU FOR ALL THAT YOU DO to help!
Board Member, Save The View Now
As the penthouse apartment began rising on the roof of the Pierhouse’s southern building in August 2015, we became concerned that it was infringing on the protected Scenic View District (“SV-1”). We hired Arek Surveying P.C. to survey the building and determine if the structure protruded into the protected region. Their measurements confirmed our suspicion that despite all the assurances from the Brooklyn Bridge Park Corp (‘BBPC’) that they would follow the SV-1 regulation, the penthouse, in fact, violated the regulation.
In October 2015, we sent Arek’s survey and report to the BBPC and the NYC Department of Buildings (“DOB”), asking them to stop the construction and remove the violation. We received no response from the BBPC, and for seven (7) weeks the DOB kept telling us they would provide their ruling shortly.
We were left with no choice, and together with the BHA we filed legal action. We did not want any doubt that we filed before the end of the statute of limitations which was fast approaching. The initial papers were filed on December 4th. In January, both sides submitted additional supporting documents and oral arguments were heard on February 4th, 2016.
In court, Judge Knipel allowed an affidavit by Councilman Levin supporting our case to be added to the record. Defendants responded to Levin’s affidavit two weeks later on February 17th. We expected to hear back from the court soon thereafter; however, it has now been over 130 days from the time the defense papers were filed. Hence, in the interest of moving the case forward, we submitted the attached letter to the court.
We have a strong case.
All the documents produced by the BBPC and Toll Brothers prior to 2015, including the RFP, the Leases and various project updates, show the boundaries of the Scenic View District in the exact same position as drawn by our surveyor. What we did not know is that in February 2015, Toll Brothers had shrunk the SV-1 region, stealing protected views from the public so as to accommodate an enlarged penthouse. The BBPC, Toll Brothers nor any other related government agency did not provide any public disclosure that the SV-1 protected region was redefined and reduced. The result is that now the penthouse is blocking legally protected views from the Promenade
We need to raise funds to support the legal battle and continue this court case. While it is frustrating beyond belief that the City, the DOB and the Courts are taking so long at each and every step, we need to prepare for the eventual case no matter what the Judge decides. Please contribute so we can continue to send the message that the City is not for sale to those who contribute heavily to public officials.
All contributions will only go towards covering our legal expenses. All STVN members volunteer their time. Thank you very much for your continued support and generous donation. http://savetheviewnow.org/donate/
P.S. I am unable to attach the letter to the judge. Please go to our website to view. Thank you!
Here is a WSJ article, that came out about 2 hours ago, about a back room deal (that even our local politicians said they didn't know about) regarding the Pier 6 proposed buildings that got scuttled at the last-minute. Please share with your network:
"Deal to Put Towers in Brooklyn Bridge Park Is Set Back. State pulls support, citing possible conflicts tied to probes of mayor" By JOSH BARBANEL and JOSH DAWSEY
May 17, 2016 9:01 p.m. ET
The ESDC meeting is still happening on Thursday at 9:30am at ESDC offices on 3rd Ave. Please do attend the ESDC meeting, if you can.
(See previous update for more information.)