Protect all Home Education Rights

£3,000 of £3,000 goal

Raised by 139 people in 16 months
Our freedom to home educate is under threat in England and Wales and the Isle of Man. Plans for updated guidance and or legislation will impact on home educators across Britain as Governments bow to pressure from local authorities and others to regulate and control ‘education otherwise’.

Home education is just that – education that takes place at home and is inseparable from our private and family life. Any plan for the Government to require sight of our children’s education, whether in the form of a compulsory register or rights to information or inspection of our children, breaches our Human Rights.

British law makes it the duty of parents, not the local authority, to ensure that the education of their children is suitable. The local authority can only get involved ‘if it appears’ the education is not suitable. It has always been that way.

Any attempt to change either guidance or law is simply the thin end of the wedge and could lead to home education being monitored, controlled, inspected and restricted in ways that makes it intolerable for children and families.

In the Isle of Man the Home Education community is tiny, there are only 57 home educated children on the entire island. There has never even been a school attendance order, yet the Government has jumped on the bandwagon with updated guidance and the threat of legislation. The case against any change in either guidance or legislation is even stronger here than elsewhere, but the fight is harder due to very weak compliance with Human Rights Legislation.

Please help us, and all home educating families, by contributing to a fund to raise £3000 for a legal opinion that will clearly explain to all Governments that rights to home educate free from reporting, control, interference and inspection are protected under the Human Rights Act.

The report will be available online to home educators to use in their fight to keep the law as it is and ensure that any new guidance fully respects our Human Rights.

Voirrey Baugh
Tristram Llewellyn Jones
Maria Ullaytt
+ Read More
The legal opinion was submitted to the Social Affairs Policy Review Committee which is an influential Committee of the Isle of Man Tynwald.

On 14 June 2019 the Committee took evidence on the opinion in public from Tristram Llewellyn Jones who currently home educates and was, himself, home educated.

The evidence session can be heard here:


The main case against any change in home education law is the absence of evidence of a problem with home education. The current UK legislation has been in place since 1944 and works today just as it did then. Local authorities rarely have to use their powers and problems with home educated children are miniscule compared to those with schooled children.

The Isle of Man Government, like the UK Government, has not made a clear, evidenced based, case for more powers. In both jurisdictions the proposed powers breach the Human Rights Act.

The Select Committee were receptive to this position and the hoped for outcome is that they recommend that there is no change in home education law in the Isle of Man.

The Isle of Man Government has said they will issue a rebuttal to the legal opinion but have yet to do so. In that event we may consider further legal advice. For the moment, however, the fund has reached its target and we are very grateful for all the support.
+ Read More
The legal opinion is now online and can be downloaded here:


The Isle of Man proposals represent the most concerted attack on home education seen in recent years and are an enhanced version of the recently withdrawn Soley Bill.

We therefore gave the advocate a wide remit and instructed him to ‘consider the extent of compatibility with the Human Rights Act 2001 of key proposals in the Education Bill 2019 which deal with, or impact upon, home education.’

The opinion can be used as a reference and guide to applying Human Rights legislation to other proposals including registration of children by local authorities.

It notes that there is no ‘pressing social need for the Bill’ is which ‘prescriptive towards coercive’ and finds that ‘The Bill primarily appears to seek to impose, via primary legislation, a particular philosophy or approach towards the provision of home education on the Isle of Man, that ‘Isle of Man home educators would be discriminated against’ and concludes ‘ . . .as drafted, the Key Proposals set out above do not comply with Article 8(1), Article 9(1) or Article 14 of the ECHR’.

We will now settle the advocates account. However, we will leave the GoFundMe open to further donations as we cannot preclude the possibility of needing more legal advice. A recently published FOI for the drafting instructions for the Bill


has revealed previously unstated plans by the Department for Education, Sport and Culture to use relatives, neighbours and landlords to check up on home educated children which means that the intrusion and Human Rights violations will be more widespread than we feared.

We will update you with the response to the consultation and the Bill’s timetable when known.

In the mean time thank you, again, for your support.
+ Read More
The legal opinion has been drafted and sent to the Department for Education, Sport and Culture as a formal response to the home education proposals in the New Education Bill consultation.

The opinion will be sent to all GoFundMe contributors on 30 March when we have settled the advocates account.



It is, otherwise, embargoed until that date.

In our view the opinion is a firm and concise legal rebuttal of the proposals to monitor and control home education in the Isle of Man.

It concludes that:

‘'as drafted, the Key Proposals set out above do not comply with Article 8(1), Article 9(1) or Article 14 of the ECHR.”

This advice is directly relevant to current and future proposals to monitor and control home education in other jurisdictions.

An interview given on Manx Radio explaining the need for the opinion can be viewed here:

Education Bill to face legal challenge

We would like to thank all who have contributed for keeping faith with us.

The fund is still short of the target and any further contributions to help us on our way would really be appreciated.
+ Read More
Thank you for your donations so far which have funded an initial consultation with the advocate. The advice is that there is a clear and straightforward evidenced case against any change in home education law but this needs to be made in a legal context in order to be heard. We now need to proceed to the next stage of funding the advocate to write the report and the £3000 target must be met to achieved this. Please help us to this goal as the arguments against compulsory registration and monitoring in the Isle of Man apply equally in England as the legislation is very similar.
+ Read More
Read a Previous Update

£3,000 of £3,000 goal

Raised by 139 people in 16 months
Your share could be bringing in donations. Sign in to track your impact.
We will never post without your permission.
In the future, we'll let you know if your sharing brings in any donations.
We weren't able to connect your Facebook account. Please try again later.
Helen Hatt
2 months ago
Javed Iqbal
3 months ago
3 months ago
Miriam Bayliss
4 months ago
4 months ago
Amy Broughton
4 months ago
Doreen Philp
4 months ago
Jonathan Adams
4 months ago
5 months ago
Ianna James
5 months ago
Use My Email Address
By continuing, you agree with the GoFundMe
terms and privacy policy
There's an issue with this Campaign Organizer's account. Our team has contacted them with the solution! Please ask them to sign in to GoFundMe and check their account. Return to Campaign

Are you ready for the next step?
Even a £5 donation can help!
Donate Now Not now
Connect on Facebook to keep track of how many donations your share brings.
We will never post on Facebook without your permission.