190
190
2

Help Us Protect Our Green Spaces

$9,280 of $9,500 goal

Raised by 218 people in 8 months
Created December 8, 2018
MTOPP and FLAC
WE HAVE FILED OUR LAWSUIT AND WE RECEIVED OUR TRO!!

Thank you for all of your donations thus far!!

Please don't stop donating, we need to be prepared to appeal if the lower courts rule against us.   All of our outreach and education to the community costs money, filing lawsuits costs money, please help in whatever way you can.

We also need to get ready for a possible lawsuit against Continuum.

Our Consulting Lawyer
Her name is Maureen Koetz and she is helping us with our lawsuit against Cornell Realty and helping with the Environmental Review for the latest Continuum Proposal, which kicked off back in February.  Her contributions have already proven to be very helpful, we have been able to add more pertinent information to our Cornell lawsuit and we will be well on our way if we need to file suit against Continuum.   She has done work with the Two Bridges community surrounding the proposed Two Bridges Development.  Below you will find the link to her website and a link to an interview that aired on WBAI's Morning Show with Maureen Koetz and David Tieu of Lower East Side Organized Neighbors.
https://planetastrategies.com/
https://archive.org/details/DavidTieuAndMaureenKoetz71417Seg


Movement to Protect the People (MTOPP) and Flower Lovers Against Corruption/Advocating for Communities (FLAC) are prepared and filed an Article 78 lawsuit against Laurie Cumbo, District 35 City Councel Rep & Majority Leader, New York City's Department of City Planning and Cornell Realty Development Corporation.  This developer has falsified important information on their rezoning application, putting our neighborhood and Brooklyn Botanic Garden at risk.

Background

We have been fighting to save Brooklyn Botanic Garden for over 1 year.

We have done everything to stop this development; shadow studies, town hall meetings, letters from elected officials demanding an Environmental Impact Statement, demonstrations, petition drive (we got over 7,000 signatures), presentations at each hearing of the Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP),  and complaints filed at the State and City environmental protection agencies.

Developers are supposed to do an environmental analysis to ensure that a project won't harm the environment.  In the case of Cornell Realty, their shadow study was done incorrectly and now they are claiming that the project won't have any negative environmental effects.

We had two teams of shadow experts analyze Cornell Realty's Study, Pratt University School of Architecture and City College School of Architecture, both stated that the Cornell Realty development will cause negative impacts on Brooklyn Botanic Garden.

History

In 1991 The Department of City Planning (DCP) placed height limits of 60/70 ft (6/7 stories) along the perimeter of Brooklyn Botanic Garden on Franklin Ave.

In 2018 Cornell Realty's application was certified by the City to build up to 223ft in this 60/70ft height limited zone.

Cornell did an Environmental Assessment Statement (EAS) which included a Shadow Study, showing no adverse environmental effects will occur.

However, they did the Shadow Study incorrectly because they did not include the 40ft Bulkhead and the FRESH program that allows 15 more feet.

With these additional heights there would be an adverse effect and thus they would be forced to address this issue and make changes to their plans.


The City Environmental Quality Review Manual (CEQR) is the official tool used by the City of New York which describes how an EAS should be performed.  It states that a developer must look at the worst case scenario in their EAS to determine if their project will have any negative effects on the environment.

In the CEQR manual, section 314.2.  http://www1.nyc.gov/assets/oec/technical-manual/08_Shadows_2014.pdf.  It defines the worst case scenario as.....

Of all "possible configurations…if the proposed projects includes special permits….the worst case scenario should include such allowances…..must include the maximum allowed floor area, all rooftop mechanical equipment.."

35162032_1544296758900301_r.jpeg

Please note in *CEQR diagram, they use the 40ft Bulkhead because this development is over 120 Ft.

The Bulkheads and FRESH Program (Special Permit)

In the NYC Zoning Text section 24-51.  http://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/zoning/zoning-text/art02c04.pdf?v=0501It defines the Bulkheads and their height allowances.

Permitted Obstructions (f) Elevator and stair bulkheads..(3) (ii)…Where the maximum permitted height of a #building# is 120 feet or greater, such obstruction are limited a maximum height of 40 ft."

In Zoning Text section Chapter 3 Fresh Program  http://www.1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans/fresh/zoning_text_amendment_2009_12_09.pdfstates in section 63-02 that Community Board 9 in Brooklyn has the FRESH Program

Section 63-22 Authorization to Modify Maximum Building Height "authorizes modifications…to allow the applicable maximum building height to be increased by 15 ft."

Additionally the application may be applied for after a Building Permit has been issued and must accompany a "signed lease from the prospective of the operator of the #FRESH food store#"

In Cornell Realty's application they state their intention to apply for the Fresh Program, which is a special permit, but they admit that they did not use it in their shadow study.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLKgTEMkREY
In this video we are talking about the Continuum Realty project, which is starting to go through the approval process now.   Shortly after our resistance to the Continuum pre-application, they withdrew their application, but they are back because the City and Cornell Realty set a precedent.     
+ Read More
Thank you to all of the folks that joined us in court to show that we are not the only people who are concerned about this development. We need your support both emotionally and financially. Thank you for your continued support!!
We will be back in court for a Traverse Hearing on September 9th at 9:30, Brooklyn Supreme Court, Rm. 456, Boyd vs. Cumbo case #1518/19
+ Read More
Please join us in court to show your opposition to this rezoning.
Friday, August 2 at 9:30am
Brooklyn Supreme Court Rm 456
Boyd vs. Councilwoman Laurie Cumbo Case #1518/19
We hope to see you there!
+ Read More
April
WE HAVE FILED OUR LAWSUIT AND WE RECEIVED OUR TRO!!
We need to be prepared to appeal if the lower courts rule against us.  
We need to get ready for a possible lawsuit against Continuum.

February
We found a lawyer to help us! We need to continue to raise funds. We would still like to meet our goal of $5000. The lawyer is Maureen Koetz, an Environmental Lawyer, who once worked regulating Air Force flights. Please help us reach our goal.
+ Read More
Read a Previous Update

$9,280 of $9,500 goal

Raised by 218 people in 8 months
Created December 8, 2018
MTOPP and FLAC
Your share could be bringing in donations. Sign in to track your impact.
   Connect
We will never post without your permission.
In the future, we'll let you know if your sharing brings in any donations.
We weren't able to connect your Facebook account. Please try again later.
AT
$5
Autumn Tarleton
24 mins ago
JS
$50
Julie Spooner
20 hours ago
$50
Anonymous
21 hours ago
$100
Lisa Burdige
23 hours ago
CB
$5
Claire Barker
1 day ago
CS
$10
carol sanjour
2 days ago
$15
Anonymous
4 days ago
$10
sandye renz
5 days ago
$50
Anonymous
5 days ago
$12
Joseph Holdner
5 days ago
or
Use My Email Address
By continuing, you agree with the GoFundMe
terms and privacy policy
There's an issue with this Campaign Organizer's account. Our team has contacted them with the solution! Please ask them to sign in to GoFundMe and check their account. Return to Campaign

Are you ready for the next step?
Even a $5 donation can help!
Donate Now Not now
Connect on Facebook to keep track of how many donations your share brings.
We will never post on Facebook without your permission.