<div>We would like to share the outcome of a legal matter that directly affected Downsview Road and the wider community.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>As many of you know, a small group of 8 households from Downsview Road, Upper Norwood, London, SE9 3XD, led by Peter and Caroline Fenech of No. 17, had been involved in a legal dispute with a developer that planned to develop nine flats next door to them. 
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>The dispute centred on a planning application submitted to Croydon Council by the developer, Hambridge Investments Limited of Hambridge Homes (Sevenoaks), to build nine flats on the site of one of the bungalows on Downsview Road. However, this land—along with neighbouring bungalows, including 283 and 285 Beulah Hill—forms part of the original Beulah Hill Estate, which is protected by a legal covenant prohibiting such a development. This restriction, established during the estate’s original planning, was known to the developer from the outset.
</div>
<div>Planning permission for this development was granted by Croydon Council in July 2020.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>To provide some historical background:
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>Although Downsview Road was developed during the 1920s and 1930s, it was specifically the land on the eastern side of the road, together with 283 and 285 Beulah Hill that formed what became known as the Beulah Hill Estate. These properties were included in a Building Scheme which imposed restrictive covenants limiting how each plot could be developed and used — both at the time and in the future. One of the central restrictions was that only a single detached private or professional dwelling could be built on each plot. This covenant formed the foundation of our legal challenge.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>In 1927, the United Methodist Church sought to purchase two available plots on the southeastern side of Downsview Road to build a new church. The landowner, Mr. William George Ingram, initially declined the sale, citing covenant restrictions that only a single detached private or professional dwelling could be built on each plot.
</div>
<div>However, Rev. Willis Bryars — who would later become the church’s first minister — approached the owners of the properties that had already been sold by Ingram and asked if they would be willing to allow a church to be built on these two plots. Fortunately for Rev. Bryars, all nine of then-owners agreed, and he secured their written consent, along with that of Mr. Ingram. The Deed of Covenant was modified and signed on 22 March 1927, formally permitting the construction of the church while preserving the original covenant restricting all other plots to single detached private dwellings.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>This historical context not only demonstrates the community spirit and legal clarity that defined the area’s early development, but also reinforces how previous generations respected the covenant. This approach by the developer, Hambridge Investments Limited, undermines the respect shown by earlier owners.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>This legal battle had spanned over five years and within this period, our group also opposed two other development proposals:
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>•	At No. 21, where Hambridge Investments Limited had an agreement with the then owner, to build nine additional flats, despite already being engaged in court proceedings for No. 19.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>•	At No. 27, where Mayle Developments sought to purchase the property, contingent upon securing planning permission for flats.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>Thanks to our group's joint efforts, both proposals were successfully opposed — initially through Croydon Council and later at appeal before the Planning Inspectorate.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>•	At Nos. 9 and 13, where both properties are owned by Shan Properties. Our legal victory will probably deter any development interest.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>•	We have also heard rumours that Downsview Methodist Church may be exploring development options, though nothing formal has yet been proposed. This was a concern for its future.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>In February of this year, following a four-day trial at the Central London County Court before His Honour Judge Dight CBE, our group — represented by Mr Martin Hutchings KC — was successful.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>The court granted an injunction preventing the development of nine flats at No. 19 and declared that the property is subject to, and bound by, the Beulah Hill Estate’s Building Scheme.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>This victory, however, came at a significant cost. The legal challenge placed a heavy burden on our residents’ group—emotionally, financially, and through the time and effort it required. We had to take the matter all the way to trial at the Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand, simply to defend a legally binding covenant that the developer knowingly ignored. Even though we set up a GoFundMe and received generous support from the local community—support for which they are immensely grateful - and despite being awarded our legal costs, the combined expenses of legal representation, the expert witness, and a necessary but costly legal insurance policy left us more than £60,000.00 out of pocket.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>The developer, fully aware of the covenant from the outset, could and should have applied to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), under section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925, to seek a modification before proceeding. Instead, they went ahead regardless, shifting the burden of enforcement onto ordinary residents. This is a serious flaw in the current planning and legal framework—one that unfairly punishes communities for standing up for what is legally and morally right.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>This was not just a victory for our community, but for any neighbourhood facing inappropriate development that disregards legal protections. We are both relieved and proud that our perseverance has paid off. It is a testament to what a community can achieve when it stands united. The decision is a clear message to developers, that they cannot ignore legal covenants and that community voices matter.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>The ruling comes as a welcome relief to many who feared the loss of character, increased traffic, and the erosion of the area’s historic character. Residents hope this outcome sends a clear message to developers to respect existing legal constraints and engage meaningfully with communities.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>Our residents’ campaign was driven by passion, commitment, and considerable personal investment—not to mention the dedicated efforts of their legal representatives, including Mr. Shaw Kelly and Mr. Martin Hutchings KC. Our group extends a heartfelt thank you to everyone who supported them throughout this long journey—whether by standing alongside us, contributing financially, or simply believing in our cause.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>If you would like to further assist with our group’s out-of-pocket expenses incurred during this lengthy process, your donation would be greatly appreciated.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div>Every donation, no matter the size, makes a meaningful difference in protecting our community.
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div><a href="https://www.facebook.com/groups/savedownsview" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener"><strong>Save Downsview Road Facebook page</strong></a><strong> </strong>
</div>
<div><br />
</div>
<div><a href="https://www.change.org/p/home-secretary-save-downsview-road-from-developers" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener"><strong>Sign the petition</strong></a><strong> </strong>
</div>

Mary McDonagh

IAN WILLIAMS

Anonymous

Mark Vaughan

Francis Glanz

Alan Mills

Ying-Hui The

Evren Turan

Mrs J M Gardner

Adrian Artenie

Harry Hutchinson

Ivo Kostadinov

Dr Tanzila Anwar

Save Downsview Road

platform

Platform is iOS

Android

Adyen Google Pay Development Audience

$opt_dummy_attribute

English only

Deprecate Stripe Legacy

dyn_template_ids

Adyen V6 Bene Transfer & MyMoney Campaign Organizers - test01

Bene transfer V6 and AdyenV6MyMoney Campaign Organizers - production

OneTrust next-app audience

fundCountryCode

NextDoor Share Option Users

Fundraisers with Reactions feature capability

fundCurrencyCode

US + Non-charity COs Only

locale

fund country is US and user language is English

personId

comms-internal-person-ids

Enhanced Story Experience Users

Suggested Goal Experience Users

user language is English and fund country: US, AU, DK, FI, IE, NO, SE, CA, GB; 

Poster share - new funds eligible (newest 9/18)

Streaming widgets beta user

paymentProcessor

3DS payment method

user language is English and fundCountry: US, AU, DK, FI, IE, NO, SE, CA, GB; 

currencyCode

Money Box Donation List Prompt Experiment Audience

GoFundMe Employees

ipAddress

Mark Rieth IP Address

Version 9.2.0 and above

Fund is in English speaking country

desktop

Android v12.11.0 and above

Platform is Android

paymentMethodType

checkoutType

Payment method type group to be vaulted on success

admin pr kit prod

EUR Donation Upsell

Share Text generation Skip Fundraiser

(prod) new funds eligible for amp12 (UGC gallery)

fintrac_cad_idv_form_v2 audience

paymentProcessorAccountId

fallback mode accounts

proCampaignId

p2p legacy startfundraising page

AMP24 New Funds Only PROD (DO NOT MODIFY)

Eligible for Profile Share Badge

countryCode

charityId

UKCharities

Federated Search Internal Testing

route.pathname community

US Donation Upsell audience 

Auto Thanks Feature Audience

Supporter Comments Eligible Funds

International Only

fundId

braze fundraiser group 

Payment Identity Transfers ATO Risk Check (Targeted) - Production

Fundraiser Saved Payment Method Rate Limit Bypass (Production)

leaderboard-partner-id-audience-givepanel

Version 9.2.1 and above

AUD Donation Upsell audience

fundraiserCountryCode is US/EN

Active Fundraiser - Smart Default Cadence

DAF Internal

Vault on success card payment method

Platform is iOS v11.0.0 and above

Desktop users

Person ids

United States (US) users

allow yuno fundraisers for test

Mexico country code

Posters INTL

NPO Profile Opted-In

iOS at or above 12.4.0

non-US recurring donors

Canada Campaign Owner Group

Fundraiser Without Meta Link

Scheduler payment tester gorup

charityCommunityId

Charities allow to be claimed unclaimed (PRD)

Canada (CA) users

UC Tipping v20250115 International

pymk_production_xplr_fe_team

Android at or above 12.2.0

Profile photo entry point audience

smart goals (fundraiser/manage) on test01

Activity Tracking v1 Beta Testing

start gfm intl allowed locales

Platform is iOS v11.2.0 and above

NPO upsell education category

unclaimed charities

prod_ach_audience

AI Chatbot Audience

amp13 only new funds (prod) (anyword auto)

UC Flow Enabled (Prod)

Payment Identity Beneficiary Verification - Production

shared notification bell audience

Custom users

ach frontend audience

Android v11.0.0 and above

Users Receiving Payments Paused Notifications

smart goals test01

Manage Coach - US English Organizers Only + new funds only

Team EGG - IP Address list

NPO recommendations prod

Fundraiser Without Instagram Deep Link

Native 11.4.0 and above

UC Tipping v20250107

Users Receiving Braze KYC Validation Failed

ai_title_page

anyword

openai

control

manual_entry

userEmail

template_id

userId

fundUrl

isCharityCo

email

appVersion

shouldBucketIntoExperiment

isEligibleForProfileBadge

partnerId

donationCadence

isActiveFundraiser

isPartner

isMobile

npoProfileOptIn

fundIsLinkedWithMeta

hasSessionDonation

categoryGroup

isCampaignOwner

fundHasInstagramDeepLink

Native 11.3.0 and above

Native 11.4.0 and higher

New funds eligible - Video Sharing (PROD)

GB Donation Upsell audience 

Auto Thanks V3 Rollout Audience

Thank you V3 testing whitelist

isRecurringFriendly

Is Recurring Friendly

Excluded funds - Video Sharing

NPO upsell animals category

NPO upsell disaster relief category

Logged In Users

CH Donation Upsell audience

Android v10.6.0 and above

NPO upsell essential needs category

NPO upsell medical category

userCurrencyCode

Localized Currency

NPO upsell cancer category

v11.5.0 and above

testAudience

pathname

Survicate

appVersion is at or above 12.8.0

Non-charity fund

isChallengeFundraiser

challenge-fundraisers

Payment Identity Launch Verification - Production

New funds eligible - Posters v2

CAD Donation Upsell Audience

Braze Email Tester

NPO Profile Opted-Out

iOS App Version

hasKnownDonors

PYMK has donors

iOS v12.3.0 and above

Save Downsview Road

Still £56,024 to go. Help us build momentum.